← Back to Episodes

Talkabout Tuesday 10: What Do You Do?

ai-in-the-air_tt-ep-10
Download MP3

Summary

Assembly meeting reflection. School is about "here's this environment, what can you do with it?" - like RPG prompts. Online transition same fundamentals. Conventional school: sit and watch someone speak - no engagement. Critique of "students damaged by not being in person" narrative - self-fulfilling, promotes helplessness. Instead: just do, figure it out.

Transcript

0:00 Welcome to Arts and Ideas in the Air, online and around Baltimore.
0:06 This is Talk About Tuesday, where I talk about something relevant to the school.
0:12 So last night we had an assembly meeting, and it was a really good assembly meeting.
0:20 Lots of good stuff, there should be an email about it.
0:26 Some of the parents who showed up were extremely supportive of the school and where we're at.
0:31 We had some good honest discussions about what to do in this current situation.
0:38 But one thing that struck me as an idea, I'm not sure where it came from in the meeting,
0:46 but just kind of floating out there was, you know, the notion that a lot of what our school
0:53 is is about students, you know, seeing this is what is around me, and now, you know, what
1:04 can I do with it, right?
1:08 It's very similar to the role-playing game that I've been running where I'll describe
1:14 some situation and just be like, what do you do?
1:18 What do you do?
1:19 Right?
1:20 That's what it is.
1:22 It's finding yourself in this environment and saying, what do I do, you know?
1:29 Do I, in person, it'd be like, oh, do I go out and play with sticks, do I go play on
1:35 the computer, do I go chat with those people over there, do I run around, do we play some
1:42 lava game?
1:45 You know, it's just finding ways of interacting with that environment for whatever reason,
1:51 for whatever purpose.
1:54 And so, you know, I think that's the transition to online is very similar.
2:04 Here's this environment, here are these things that one can do, what can you do with it?
2:11 So fundamentally, the same elements, you know, are there.
2:17 Now, it's not as easy to be physical and socially connected as in person.
2:27 It's much harder to observe what other people are doing, which is, I think, a critical component
2:32 because we inspire one another.
2:36 But it's still the case that our students are able to actively engage in an environment
2:44 that supports them, trying to figure out what to do with where they found themselves.
2:52 It's very different than conventional school, which says, you know, in this online environment,
2:57 sit in this chair and watch this person speak at you for like half an hour or an hour or
3:03 whatever.
3:05 You know, it's just, there's no engagement with the environment or life in that model.
3:14 It's all about being part of someone else's narrative and story.
3:19 But that's not what, well, it's really not what any life form is or ought to be.
3:27 But it's certainly not something that humans who, you know, grow up in an environment where
3:34 people say that they're free, it's just totally inappropriate, whereas our environment is
3:39 exactly what it is.
3:40 It's like, yeah, you are free.
3:42 You're free to decide.
3:43 You're free to choose.
3:45 You're free to shut down.
3:46 You're free to expand.
3:48 You're free to explore.
3:49 You're free to propose your activities, you know, you're free to do whatever you want
3:55 to do.
3:56 You know, as long as you don't break the rules of the community.
4:02 And so, you know, it's just such a vastly different thing.
4:08 And so there is an opportunity here to really learn something valuable.
4:17 It's not the same as in person.
4:18 There's a lot of things that are just really wonderful about being in person with other
4:23 members of one's community.
4:27 But it's still not hopeless.
4:28 It's not nothing.
4:33 And you know, I hope everyone is trying to figure out how they can participate in one
4:39 way or another with the community, with their life as it is.
4:47 You know, there is this narrative being said, you know, across the nation that students
4:54 not being able to be in person, in school, that they're being damaged long-term.
5:00 And while that, you know, may or may not be true, I think the narrative itself is such
5:04 a bad narrative.
5:06 It's one of sort of helplessness and it's one of, you know, almost self-fulfilling.
5:15 If you tell someone that they are damaged, then they will very likely come to believe
5:20 that because it's pretty easy to view yourself as damaged.
5:24 It, you know, doesn't require that much effort to be, "Yeah, I can't do this."
5:32 That's pretty much it, right, versus trying to do something where it's a lot of active
5:37 inaction.
5:38 And then, of course, it kind of feeds on itself.
5:41 So you know, I'm always very skeptical of negative narratives, whether they be true
5:47 or not, I think it's very important to ask, "Well, why are we saying this narrative?
5:54 What are we trying to accomplish?"
5:58 And you know, so I think you can argue that in person is a really great thing to have
6:06 and we should fight for it, but I think the narrative of, "Oh, it's all hopeless, y'all
6:12 are getting hurt," is a bad one and should go away.
6:18 Instead it should be a narrative of, "Okay, here is this environment, what can you make
6:27 of it?
6:28 What can you do?
6:29 Try to figure something out, try to do something.
6:32 Just do.
6:33 Just do."
6:34 All right, well, I think that's about enough for today.
6:43 You know, like, I guess one example is just this podcast itself.
6:49 I wasn't thinking about doing things like this, but here I am and I'm doing it.
6:54 Why?
6:55 You know, that just seemed like a nice way of asynchronously connecting with people.
7:05 So I tried it and I'm doing it.
7:09 Figure out stuff to do.
7:10 That's how it goes.
7:11 All right, well, you all have a good one.
7:14 Until next time.